A major independent review commissioned by government has warned that Britain is at risk of creating a “lost generation” unless radical reforms are implemented to help young people into education, training and work.
In From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation, former Cabinet minister Alan Milburn argues that the UK must fundamentally rethink how it supports young people, replacing fragmented systems with a new participation-focused model designed to ensure every young person has the opportunity to learn or earn.
The report comes amid growing concern over record levels of young people classified as not in education, employment or training (NEET), with almost one million young people currently outside all three categories. According to the review, one in eight young people are now NEET, with six in 10 having never held a job.
Milburn says the challenge extends well beyond welfare reform and requires action across education, skills, health, employment and local government.
“The young people I have met over the last year are not asking for an easier life. They are asking for a fair chance to build one.
Our generation has a responsibility to give them that chance.”
‘A fork in the road’ for Britain
The review presents what Milburn describes as a clear choice between maintaining the status quo or delivering a substantial overhaul of the systems that support young people.
It proposes a new national ambition under which every young person should be "learning, earning or actively participating" by 2036, with the UK aiming to reduce its NEET rate to around 5% and become one of Europe’s strongest performers on youth participation.
Milburn argues that the economic and social costs of inaction are becoming unsustainable.
The report estimates that higher youth participation could boost UK GDP by more than 0.4% annually while reducing welfare spending by £3.6 billion each year by 2036.
“Our country is at a fork in the road. Go on as we are and see the NEET crisis grow. Or change course and make the difficult changes that can shift the trajectory.”
Five major reforms proposed
At the heart of the review is a package of reforms designed to transform youth participation.
The report proposes:
- A more active youth labour market with incentives for employers to create more first jobs, apprenticeships and work experience opportunities.
- An education system focused not only on qualifications but successful transitions into employment and further learning.
- Earlier health intervention to tackle the growing impact of poor mental health on participation.
- A welfare system that prioritises pathways into work while maintaining protections for those unable to participate.
- The creation of a new locally delivered Youth Opportunity Service to bring employment, education, health and welfare support together.
Milburn argues that current arrangements are failing because responsibility is spread across multiple organisations and government departments.
“This is a whole system failure. In short, Britain has a chronic problem. It is getting worse, not better. And there is neither an existing system nor plan capable of dealing with it.”

Employers given central role
A significant focus of the review is the role of employers in rebuilding what Milburn describes as the “first rung” of the career ladder.
The report proposes financial incentives for businesses that recruit young people who have been NEET for six months or more, including payments of £3,000 per recruit, rising further for employers hiring disabled young people, care leavers or those facing significant barriers.
It also recommends targeted reductions in employer National Insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24 in sectors such as retail and hospitality, which account for more than a third of youth employment.
Large employers would be encouraged to join a new employer-led movement called First Chance, focused on expanding access to first jobs, apprenticeships and work experience opportunities.
The public sector would also be expected to lead by example, with a target that 11% of the Civil Service entry-level workforce should be aged between 16 and 24 by 2032.
Education reforms aimed at prevention
The review argues that tackling youth inactivity requires intervention long before young people leave education.
Recommendations include increasing school readiness to 90% by 2036, improving literacy and numeracy outcomes, strengthening support for children at risk of disengagement, and making Risk of NEET Indicator (RONI) tools mandatory in schools.
Milburn also supports a stronger role for technical education, expansion of apprenticeships, growth in further education opportunities and the introduction of new vocational qualifications.
The report says schools should focus on developing aptitudes and employability alongside academic achievement to better prepare young people for a rapidly changing labour market increasingly shaped by automation and artificial intelligence.
A ‘working state’ for a changing economy
Central to Milburn’s argument is the belief that the post-war welfare state must evolve to reflect modern challenges.
While recognising the importance of the welfare state's historic protective role, the report argues that the biggest threat facing many young people today is becoming disconnected from education and employment before adult life has properly begun.
The proposed “working state” would shift public policy towards participation and prevention, ensuring support is organised around helping young people engage in education, training or employment wherever possible.
“The old welfare state needs to evolve into a new working state which has maximising youth participation as its central objective.”
Milburn concludes that Britain’s response must be measured not by short-term initiatives but by whether it creates lasting opportunities for future generations.
“A new settlement is needed if the lost generation is to become the work generation.”
The Local Government Organisation has responded to the review, with Chair Cllr Eamonn O’Brien saying:
“This report highlights the scale of the youth unemployment challenge, and the reforms and resources that will be needed to tackle it. It recognises the importance of local leaders and how they are best placed to deliver preventative measures and solutions for their area."
"Councils across England, including those in devolution areas working closely with Strategic Authorities, need a clearly defined role in the design and delivery of any new system. They have the convening powers and knowledge of communities and employers, and need adequate resources and time to deliver.
“Better support for young people must look at the whole system, including any forthcoming welfare reform that supports them into work, training or education. Councils are ready to work with Government as it considers how to implement the recommendations and can also make a difference now with reforms to the Youth Guarantee to maximise the benefit to young people and employers.”
Image credit: iStock
