Latest Public Sector News

13.03.17

Betts: GM devo deal a halfway house to aligning health and social care

Establishing clear lines of accountability to deliver health and social care integration is going to be one of the major challenges facing the sector going forward, the chair of the Communities and Local Government (CLG) Committee has told PSE – adding that GM devolution is a “halfway house towards it, but still leaves some of the questions unanswered”.

Following last week’s Spring Budget, where the chancellor announced an extra £2bn for social care and promised a green paper, Clive Betts MP said: “Obviously, we are pleased that the chancellor has recognised that the problems of social care need more money, but are disappointed that he hadn’t gone as far as the committee asked.”

He added that his committee also requested a National Audit Office review to establish a figure that everyone could agree on with regards to the social care funding gap, but “ the government didn’t even mention that”.

“To pluck another £1bn over two years and say that is enough misses the point,” argued Betts. “The chancellor can’t be certain it is enough; he has no credible evidence to back it. And we could be back here in a year’s time having the same argument.”

Discussing the GM health devo model, whose ambitions could be ‘gnawed away’ due to social care cuts, he told us: “Pooling budgets is sometimes called joint commissioning, and there are different ways of doing it.

“The one difficulty with all these things is that they tend to work until they go wrong, and then everybody blames everyone else. You really have to have clear lines of accountability, but currently health and social care have very different accountability systems. Social care is accountable to, ultimately, elected councillors on the local authority. Health is accountable to the secretary of state.

“I don’t think government yet has a clear view of how that works. The Manchester system is a halfway house towards it, but still leaves some of the questions unanswered.

“These are very different systems, and that is going to be a challenge for the future.”

While admitting that health and social care integration can go some way to reducing the stress on both systems, the committee chair noted that as NHS England’s chief executive, Simon Stevens, told them, “integrating health and social care will bring benefits, but it won’t solve the problem of social care funding in the long term”.

The Sheffield South East MP added: “If anyone thinks all we have to do is get social care and health to integrate and then everything will be fine, then they are missing the point. We are still going to have a continuing need for extra funding for social care, simply because of demographics.”

A CIPFA survey recently revealed that households in England face the highest council tax rise in a decade, on average a rise of 4%, as local authorities attempt to tackle the social care shortfall.

Betts, whose committee is carrying out an inquiry into adult social care, said: “There are massive challenges ahead. No one has given us evidence that it could all be funded by the public sector.

“Most people want to see there is a strong local element in it, with local accountability. How you put that together, recognising the significant changes about localisation of business rates, which are coming as well, are issues we need to reflect on.

“We have, however, had clear evidence from the local government sector saying that the demand for social care is going to go up faster than business rates will.

“Those are problems in the system that are going to need long-term resolution. We have had lots of problems presented to us, but not a comprehensive solution. That is what the green paper should be looking at.”

Top image: John Stilwell

Have you got a story to tell? Would you like to become a PSE columnist? If so, click here 

Comments

There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment

 

related

public sector executive tv

more videos >

last word

National policies won’t fix local problems

National policies won’t fix local problems

Andrew Carter, the recently-appointed chief executive of Centre for Cities, argues that the new government will only succeed if it focuses on implementing policies that are adaptable to place-based more > more last word articles >

public sector focus

View all News

comment

Innovation in commissioning services

26/06/2017Innovation in commissioning services

Malcolm Harbour CBE, who wrote Parliament’s first report on innovatio... more >
Engaging the voluntary sector: how to make devolution a success

26/06/2017Engaging the voluntary sector: how to make devolution a success

Paul Winyard, senior policy officer at the National Council for Voluntary O... more >

interviews

HSCN: The enabler for a more joined-up public sector

26/06/2017HSCN: The enabler for a more joined-up public sector

Mark Hall, Chief Assurance Officer at Redcentric, discusses NHS Digital&rsq... more >

most read

the raven's daily blog

Councillors celebrated in Queen’s Birthday Honours list 2017

19/06/2017Councillors celebrated in Queen’s Birthday Honours list 2017

A number of local government leaders and figures have been named in the Queen’s 2017 Birthday Honours list. The list recognises the achievements of people across a ... more >
read more blog posts from 'the raven' >

editor's comment

15/06/2017Challenges remain

As PSE went to press, we were days away from finding out which political party or parties would be leading the country following Theresa May’s decision to call a snap general election for 8 June.  Whoever enters the door at No.10, irrelevant of their political colour, is faced with serious challenges, from social care to the NHS, housing to the economy, and, of course, the all-consuming and imminent Brexit negotiations which will have ramifications for generations to... read more >