National and Devolved Politics

14.06.18

On a cliff edge: The Barnett Formula

Source: PSE June/July 2018

David Phillips, associate director at the Institute for Fiscal Studies, gives his analysis of the Barnett Formula post-Brexit and asks: how will we replace EU funding to the devolved governments and local areas of the UK?

The UK is due to leave the EU at 11pm on 29 March 2019. However, we will continue our regular contributions to the EU’s budget and take part in EU schemes supporting farming, regional economic development, science and innovation and a host of other areas for another 21 months after that. That means we have some time to get the design of new programmes to replace these EU schemes right.

A key issue is how funding will be allocated to the various nations and regions of the UK. The Welsh and Scottish Finance committees are currently holding inquiries on this issue. One question the Scottish committee has asked is whether the Barnett Formula is suitable for use in allocating replacement funding to the devolved governments. The answer is a resounding no.

First, the Barnett Formula says nothing about what the initial level of funding for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland should be. It just says that each year, the change in funding should depend on the cash change in funding for England and their relative populations. We would still need a way to work out the initial funding levels.

But in itself, that is not an insurmountable problem. We could, for instance, take the levels of funding each nation gets from EU schemes as the starting point and use the Barnett Formula to calculate funding for subsequent years, right?

Well, we could - but it wouldn’t be a good idea. The Barnett Formula aims to give each nation the same cash-terms pounds-per-person change in funding each year. It takes no account of differences in initial levels of funding per person, in funding needs, or in the outcomes delivered. 

Application of the formula can therefore lead to a squeeze in funding over time if a nation initially receives more funding per person than England. For existing EU programmes, that is true for Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales. For instance, the high level of funding the Welsh Government received for economic development in West Wales and the Valleys – one of the poorest regions in western Europe – means it receives over 3.5 times the EU funding per person that England does. The squeeze happens because a given pounds-per-person change is a smaller percentage change the higher the initial funding level.

In our submission to the Welsh Assembly, we looked at what this squeeze could mean for the amount the Welsh Government received in funds to replace EU schemes. In doing this we assumed inflation of 2% and growth of funding in England of 2% above inflation each year, roughly in line with long-term economic growth. The Figure shows what we found. 

 Projected levels of replacement funding per person if Barnett Formula used for allocation Source Authors calculations using EU funding data, ONS

While funding per person in England would be growing in real terms – by about 1.5% a year after accounting for 0.5% population growth a year – funding in Wales would be falling. It would fall an average of almost 1% a year in the 2020s and 0.5% a year in the 2030s. By 2050, funding would have fallen from more than 3.5 times the English level to less than 2 times. Similar – albeit less dramatic – squeezes would also take place in Scotland and Northern Ireland. These squeezes would happen irrespective of whether the level of need in the devolved nations stayed the same or even rose relative to England. This seems far from desirable.

So if the Barnett Formula is not suitable, how should funding be allocated? The key thing is that the allocation method is compatible with the aims of the replacement programmes. That is likely to mean different methods are used for funding for farming, regional development and science and innovation.

The UK and devolved governments need to work out what their funding objectives in these different realms are. Is it environmental improvement? Is it general support for services and infrastructure in deprived areas? Or the promotion of faster economic growth, even if that takes place in already less-deprived areas? Do they want to support the best science wherever it takes place, or encourage more innovation in disadvantaged regions? Should the money be ring-fenced for particular purposes or should devolved and local governments be able to spend it as they see fit?

And finally, there is a case for some funding decisions to be centralised. For instance, with science and innovation funding, there could be benefits to deciding which projects to fund at a UK-wide level, or seeking to remain in Europe-wide schemes. That would help ensure the best projects get funded, and support collaborative projects that operate across borders. 

Find out more at the Institute for Fiscal Studies. 

 

Enjoying PSE? Subscribe here to receive our weekly news updates or click here to receive a copy of the magazine!

Comments

There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment

 

related

public sector executive tv

more videos >

latest public sector news

London council ‘negligent and in denial’ over tower blocks at risk of collapse

22/06/2018London council ‘negligent and in denial’ over tower blocks at risk of collapse

Two tower blocks in North London are at risk of collapse, with the area’s council announcing it wants to begin re-housing residents “... more >
Christchurch allowed into High Court over Dorset council merger battle

22/06/2018Christchurch allowed into High Court over Dorset council merger battle

An ongoing battle between Christchurch Borough Council and a planned council merger has been given the go-ahead to proceed to the High Court. ... more >
Government does not ‘currently have understanding’ of skills businesses need going through Brexit

22/06/2018Government does not ‘currently have understanding’ of skills businesses need going through Brexit

Government departments “do not have sufficient understanding” of what skills UK businesses need, or how Brexit will impact the supply... more >

editor's comment

25/10/2017Take a moment to celebrate

Devolution, restructuring and widespread service reform: from a journalist’s perspective, it’s never been a more exciting time to report on the public sector. That’s why I could not be more thrilled to be taking over the reins at PSE at this key juncture. There could not be a feature that more perfectly encapsulates this... read more >

last word

The importance of openness after Grenfell

The importance of openness after Grenfell

Following the recent Grenfell Tower tragedy, Lord Porter, chairman of the LGA, argues that if the public are going to have faith in the safety testing process then everything must be out in the o... more > more last word articles >
Christchurch allowed into High Court over Dorset council merger battle

22/06/2018Christchurch allowed into High Court over Dorset council merger battle

An ongoing battle between Christchurch Borough Council and a planned council merger has been given the go-ahead to proceed to the High Court. Last month, Christchurch council outlined its pl... more >
Government under fire for lack of care funding after £20bn NHS pledge

18/06/2018Government under fire for lack of care funding after £20bn NHS pledge

Council chiefs have heavily criticised Theresa May for not including social care funding in her promise to increase cash resources by £20bn annually for the NHS to mark the service’s ... more >

the raven's daily blog

The work of the vanguards can help overcome the challenges of integrated care

29/05/2018The work of the vanguards can help overcome the challenges of integrated care

Following the announcement of the second wave of integrated care systems (ICSs), NHS Providers, the NHS Confederation, NHS Clinical Commissioners (NHSCC) and the LGA reflect on how lessons learnt by members from across the four organisations – that have designed and worked together as part of the vanguards – will support the j... more >
read more blog posts from 'the raven' >

comment

Grenfell, one year on

18/06/2018Grenfell, one year on

In the year since the Grenfell Tower disaster, the LGA has been working tirelessly to ramp up fire safety regulations and ban ‘desktop&rsqu... more >
Brexit's long shadow over devolution

18/06/2018Brexit's long shadow over devolution

The EU Referendum and the stop-start Brexit negotiations have left a looming shadow of uncertainty over devolution in the UK, writes Anthony Sala... more >
Decisions, decisions

18/06/2018Decisions, decisions

The true social value of procurement comes from asking challenging questions and thinking outside the box, argues Melissa Bell, sustainable procu... more >
Finding the balance

18/06/2018Finding the balance

Douglas White, head of advocacy at the Carnegie UK Trust, evaluates the risk-benefit relationship of data sharing within the public sector, highl... more >

interviews

Data at the heart of digital transformation

03/04/2018Data at the heart of digital transformation

SPONSORED INTERVIEW Grant Caley, UK & Ireland chief technologist at NetApp, speaks to PSE’s Luana Salles about the benefits of movin... more >
GDPR: The public sector scarecrow

03/04/2018GDPR: The public sector scarecrow

SPONSORED INTERVIEW PSE’s Josh Mines chats to Martin de Martini, CIO of Y Soft, about what the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)... more >
Keeping London safe

05/03/2018Keeping London safe

Theo Blackwell, London’s first-ever chief digital officer (CDO), speaks to PSE’s Luana Salles about the role he plays in ensuring the... more >
BIM: Digitising the public sector

19/02/2018BIM: Digitising the public sector

PSE’s Josh Mines talks to Stephen Crompton, CTO at GroupBC, and Stuart Bell, the company’s sales and marketing director, about how Bu... more >

public sector focus

  • 12/06/2018G-Cloud 10: small changes, big opportunities

    Rafael Cortes, Foehn head of marketing, explains how G-Cloud 10 should be a catalyst for innovative solutions and not a source of complacency. It was...
  • 04/06/2018Targets and tribulations

    David Willett, corporate director at The Open University, walks us through the university’s research into the apprenticeship levy, as well as...
  • 30/04/2018The legacy of Grenfell

    PSE’s Seamus McDonnell looks at the reactions of councils and the government to the Grenfell Tower fire, from the immediate aftermath to the...
View all News