Interviews

13.04.17

New social care funding misses the point

Source: PSE Apr/May 17

Clive Betts MP, chair of the Communities and Local Government (CLG) Committee, reflects on the social care funding released in this year’s Spring Budget and the government’s much-anticipated Green Paper.

While it is welcome news that the chancellor has recognised that the struggling adult social care sector needs extra funding, it is highly likely that we will be having similar arguments about the crisis come next year, the chair of the CLG Committee has told PSE. 

Speaking to us after the Spring Budget, where Philip Hammond announced a further £1bn for social care in 2017-18, Clive Betts said the funding falls well short of the £1.5bn his committee recommended was necessary to plug the gap in funding for the next year and provide adequate relief from the immediate pressures faced by local care services. 

“We also said as a committee that there are so many different estimates of what the position is going forward, for the rest of the Parliament, that we thought the easiest and most objective way was to ask the National Audit Office (NAO) to do a review of what the position was and, very quickly, they could come up with a figure which we could then all agree on,” he explained. 

“The government didn’t mention that. I think, just to pluck another billion pounds over two years, to say that’s enough, misses the point. The chancellor can’t be certain it is enough, he doesn’t have any credible evidence to back it. We could be back here in a year’s time having the same argument.” 

While the committee accepted there needed to be a quick fix for this financial year, noted Betts, there was also a consensus that a little bit more reflection and analysis would have helped settle a longstanding argument. 

Cross-party Green Paper 

While at the despatch box, Hammond said “the government will set out its thinking on the options for the future financing of social care in a Green Paper later this year”. 

Betts, whose committee completed its inquiry into adult social care as PSE went to press, recognised that for the longer term there needs to be a review. “We are pleased to see a Green Paper in the offing, although there is no clear timetable yet. We will certainly be asking questions about that,” he argued.  

“We, as a committee, said, ideally, that looking for the long term we should get agreement on a cross-party basis. That is a cross-party committee saying, unanimously, that for the long term we need it on a cross-party basis. There is no mention of that, so far. 

“Again, ideally, we ought to have the cross-party talks before we get to the Green Paper, but at the very least, we should have them after the Green Paper is produced.” 

Discussing the evidence presented to his committee, Betts reflected: “No one has come forward and said: ‘this is how we are going to solve it’. What we have seen is that there are massive challenges. No one has given us evidence that it could all be funded by the public sector, and it will be all out of national taxation.” 

He added that one thing most people want to see is a strong local element, with local accountability. However, how you put that together, while recognising the significant changes about the localisation of business rates that are also on the horizon, are issues that need to be reflected on. 

“We have had lots of problems presented to us, but not a comprehensive solution. That is what the Green Paper should be looking at,” he stated. “One thing that the chancellor did say, in addition, was that he ruled out any change to a tax on people’s assets once they die. 

“If you are going to do a complete and comprehensive review of the system, you don’t begin by ruling things out. You say we have to consider the options. I don’t think it is helpful to begin by ruling out something that could, eventually, be worth considering.” 

c. Victoria Jones - PA edit

Health and social care integration 

Discussing health and social care integration, Betts stated that NHS England’s chief executive, Simon Stevens, told his committee that while it can bring benefits, “it is not going to solve the problem of social care funding in the long term”. 

“It won’t solve it,” said Betts resolutely. “If anyone thinks all we have to do is get health and social care integrated and everything will be fine, they are missing the point. We are still going to have a continuing need for extra funding for social care, simply because of demographics. 

“Pooling budgets is sometimes called joint commissioning, and there are different ways of doing it, but the one difficulty with all these things is that they tend to work until something goes wrong. And then everyone blames everyone else for what happened. You really have got to have clear lines of accountability and, of course, currently health and social care have very different accountability systems. 

“Social care is accountable to, ultimately, elected councillors on the local authority. Health is accountable to the secretary of state. I don’t think government yet has a clear view of how that works. That is going to be a challenge for the future. The Manchester system is a halfway house towards it, but leaves some of those questions unanswered.”

For more information

W: www.tinyurl.com/CLG-Committee

© Victoria Jones - PA

Comments

There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment

 

public sector executive tv

more videos >

latest public sector news

Switch to Universal Credit doubles number of referrals to foodbanks

25/04/2017Switch to Universal Credit doubles number of referrals to foodbanks

Areas where Universal Credit has been rolled out to single people, couples and families have seen a 16.85% increase in the number of people being... more >
Maintaining the momentum for further devolution

25/04/2017Maintaining the momentum for further devolution

Ahead of this year’s mayoral elections, Lord Kerslake, the former head of the Civil Service, tells PSE’s David Stevenson why the argu... more >
Public sector can lead the UK to an ultra-low emission future

25/04/2017Public sector can lead the UK to an ultra-low emission future

Poppy Welch, head of Go Ultra Low, explains why the public sector has the potential to shape and accelerate the UK automotive market to be entire... more >
149x260 PSE Subscribe button

the raven's daily blog

Engaging voters ahead of May’s elections

24/04/2017Engaging voters ahead of May’s elections

Emma Hartley, head of campaigns at the Electoral Commission, discusses the importance of a collaborative approach to engage voters ahead of this year’s elections.  It’s vital that voters can easily participate in every type of election so that democracy can work. One of the challenges for the Electoral Commission when new... more >
read more blog posts from 'the raven' >

comment

Public sector can lead the UK to an ultra-low emission future

25/04/2017Public sector can lead the UK to an ultra-low emission future

Poppy Welch, head of Go Ultra Low, explains why the public sector has the potential to shape and accelerate the UK automotive market to be entire... more >
Employee financial wellbeing in the public sector

25/04/2017Employee financial wellbeing in the public sector

Charles Cotton, performance and reward adviser to the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD), analyses the financial wellbeing o... more >
Wigan Council: embracing digital transformation

25/04/2017Wigan Council: embracing digital transformation

Alison McKenzie-Folan, deputy chief executive, director customer transformation at Wigan Council, explains why local authorities, as digital lead... more >
Oxfordshire devolution will boost UK economy

21/04/2017Oxfordshire devolution will boost UK economy

Peter Sloman, chief executive of Oxford City Council, argues that pursuing devolution rather than restructuring local government in the county is... more >

last word

Parliament cannot solve homelessness through legislation alone

Parliament cannot solve homelessness through legislation alone

Cllr Michelle Lowe, deputy leader and cabinet member for housing and health at Sevenoaks District Council, argues that if the government is really serious about combating homelessness they will w... more > more last word articles >

editor's comment

11/04/2017A watershed moment in British politics

The government has now officially triggered Article 50, formally starting the process of Britain’s exit from the EU. How this will affect local government, the wider public sector and the Civil Service remains to be seen, but the likelihood of it being plain sailing with the enormity of the task ahead seems rather unlikely.  It... read more >

public sector focus

A period of inevitable risk

25/04/2017A period of inevitable risk

Dr Daniel Dresner, information and cyber secu... more >
Using data to enhance public services

25/04/2017Using data to enhance public services

Shane Green, programme manager for business i... more >