Economy and Infrastructure

23.05.18

Carillion board’s belief government would bail it out contributed to collapse

The Carillion papers identify “clear and compelling problems” which the government had the opportunity to deal with in the months leading up to its collapse, according to the Public Accounts Committee.

Back in January, the House of Commons agreed that the government’s risk assessments of its strategic suppliers should be released to the committee. Although they are subjective documents intended as confidential advice, they are no longer considered to contain live and material risks since the company is no longer trading.

Each strategic supplier is assessed on a red-amber-green (RAG) scale, with some being designated a black high risk status.

According to the Carillion assessments, the company had been rated amber due to its performance against contracts with the Ministry of Defence and Ministry of Justice.

The government did not downgrade Carillion to red until it had issued a profit warning in July 2017, before which the government appears not to have been aware of the company’s financial distress.

Officials recommended a provisional black rating be allocated to the company in November 2017, but the Cabinet Office did not confirm the designation.

The company collapsed less than two months later.

Chair of the committee, Meg Hillier, argued that there is “great secrecy” surrounding the large contracts that the government has become dependent on in order to deliver public projects and services.

“If a company providing a number of these contracts fails, this is bad news for service users and the taxpayer,” she said.

While there are commercial sensitivities around the relationship between the government and suppliers, with a potential impact on jobs and small businesses should certain information be made public, Hillier said that the strategic supplier risk assessments give rise to many questions.

“We have been mindful of the workers and businesses who could lose out through no fault of their own if certain information is in the public domain.

“But equally we are concerned about the lack of transparency and its potential to create an environment where poor practice takes root,” she explained.

“The Carillion papers identify clear and compelling problems with the business in the months leading to its collapse. Government had the opportunity to deal with them,” she said.

Hillier explained that although the government did not bail out Carillion, with the company going into liquidation, costs and responsibilities were inherited that were ultimately borne by the taxpayer.

“The fall-out from Carillion’s collapse and the resulting burden on the public purse is still not clear. We will be seeking clarity on these critical matters and probing suppliers and government about what they are doing to ensure such a catastrophic failure is not repeated,” she added.

Deputy chair of the committee, Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, described the RAG scale for strategic suppliers as “too slow and clunky”, pointing out that profit warnings were issued in July and September 2017 and yet a high risk recommendation was not made until the end of November 2017.

“The City, in contrast, knew well before July 2017 that Carillion was in trouble,” he said.

“Too many government facilities contracts were concentrated in one large firm giving the impression that it was too big to fail, hence the perception that the government would bail them out when push came to shove,” added Clifton-Brown.

He argued that the Carillion board’s “erroneous belief” that the government would not let the company collapse appears to have contributed to the failure to take necessary action to save the company and prevent the “sad loss of jobs and damage to numerous suppliers and subcontractors.”

Top image: PA Wire

 

Enjoying PSE? Subscribe here to receive our weekly news updates or click here to receive a copy of the magazine!

Comments

There are no comments. Why not be the first?

Add your comment

 

public sector executive tv

more videos >

latest public sector news

CIPFA warns councils against exposing public money to risk in commercial property investment

19/10/2018CIPFA warns councils against exposing public money to risk in commercial property investment

Councils have been warned not to expose public funds to “unnecessary or unquantified risk” when borrowing to invest in commercial pro... more >
Oxford housing plan to build ‘upwards’ approved by city council

19/10/2018Oxford housing plan to build ‘upwards’ approved by city council

Plans to build “upwards” for the first time in Oxford city centre in a bid to tackle a major shortage of housing have been approved b... more >
Council strips contract from NHS trusts and hands it to Virgin after High Court row

18/10/2018Council strips contract from NHS trusts and hands it to Virgin after High Court row

Lancashire County Council (LCC) has awarded a controversial £104m healthcare contract to Virgin Care for the second time after a hearing in... more >

editor's comment

25/10/2017Take a moment to celebrate

Devolution, restructuring and widespread service reform: from a journalist’s perspective, it’s never been a more exciting time to report on the public sector. That’s why I could not be more thrilled to be taking over the reins at PSE at this key juncture. There could not be a feature that more perfectly encapsulates this... read more >

last word

The importance of openness after Grenfell

The importance of openness after Grenfell

Following the recent Grenfell Tower tragedy, Lord Porter, chairman of the LGA, argues that if the public are going to have faith in the safety testing process then everything must be out in the o... more > more last word articles >
CIPFA warns councils against exposing public money to risk in commercial property investment

19/10/2018CIPFA warns councils against exposing public money to risk in commercial property investment

Councils have been warned not to expose public funds to “unnecessary or unquantified risk” when borrowing to invest in commercial property in a statement from CIPFA. In a joint s... more >
Oxford housing plan to build ‘upwards’ approved by city council

19/10/2018Oxford housing plan to build ‘upwards’ approved by city council

Plans to build “upwards” for the first time in Oxford city centre in a bid to tackle a major shortage of housing have been approved by the city council. The new plans will focus ... more >

the raven's daily blog

What cities should become

15/10/2018What cities should become

Tom Leaver, project manager at Future Cities Catapult, examines the rationale behind the creation of the City Data Sharing Toolkit, and explores how this is driving a seismic shift in how cities evolve into our data-rich future. We’re used to big-screen sci-fi future cities being dystopian monoliths to everything wrong with the worl... more >
read more blog posts from 'the raven' >

comment

Inspiring leadership in social value

15/10/2018Inspiring leadership in social value

We have learned a lot since the last National Social Value Conference, with many organisations both in the public and private sectors now embeddi... more >
Is fair funding possible, or pie in the sky?

15/10/2018Is fair funding possible, or pie in the sky?

David Phillips, associate director at the Institute for Fiscal Studies, discusses the current health of local government finance, and how a bette... more >
Keeping the momentum of the Northern Powerhouse

15/10/2018Keeping the momentum of the Northern Powerhouse

On 6 September, the biggest decision-makers of the north joined forces to celebrate and debate how to drive innovation and improvement through th... more >
The Convention of the North

15/10/2018The Convention of the North

Steve Rotheram, mayor of the Liverpool City Region, discusses the findings of the very first Convention of the North, which was held in Newcastle... more >

interviews

Keeping the momentum of the Northern Powerhouse

15/10/2018Keeping the momentum of the Northern Powerhouse

On 6 September, the biggest decision-makers of the north joined forces to celebrate and debate how to drive innovation and improvement through th... more >
Michael King: Time for Ombudsman reform

06/08/2018Michael King: Time for Ombudsman reform

Michael King first joined the Local Government Ombudsman service back in 2004 as deputy ombudsman. At the start of 2017, he was appointed as the ... more >
Helping a city understand itself

06/08/2018Helping a city understand itself

SPONSORED INTERVIEW The urban landscape is changing. How can local authorities keep up with citizen behaviour? Stephen Leece, managing directo... more >
Modern policing: the future is bright

06/08/2018Modern policing: the future is bright

SPONSORED INTERVIEW The public sector, and policing in particular, has often been criticised as being slow to adapt to change. But now, says L... more >

public sector focus

View all News