Audit, Inspection and Safety


Government must encourage council scrutiny ‘culture change’

The government has to encourage a culture change within local councils in order to improve the quality of overview and scrutiny plans.

The Communities and Local Government Commons Select Committee found that scrutiny is not always independent of the executive, and this could stop councils improving the quality of services.

Following a review, the committee produced a report saying that systems meant to scrutinise the performance of services are not held in high enough esteem – leading to a lack of constructive challenge to improve services for residents.

The report recommends that overview and scrutiny committees should report to an authority’s full council rather than just the executive.

It also says that the groups should be distinct from any executive, with them able to give evidence as witnesses but not sit on the committee itself.

In addition, the committee recommended that overview groups in local authorities should also have a role in monitoring the performance of LEPs and that central government commits more funding to the scrutiny of mayoral combined authorities.

“Scrutiny is marginalised at too many local authorities, which in extreme cases can contribute to severe service failures, letting down council taxpayers and those that rely on services,” commented Clive Betts, chair of the Communities and Local Government Committee.

“Scrutiny of those in power is a vital part of any democratic system and has huge benefits for all. We are calling on the government to strengthen guidance to make overview and scrutiny committees truly independent of those they are charged with holding to account and to make sure the process is properly funded and respected.

“Only by rebalancing the system and ensuring scrutiny is held in high esteem will we see better decisions and the outcomes that residents who pay for council services deserve.”

The select committee also said scrutiny groups should have access to financial and performance data held by the council and that members of the public and service users should have a greater say in any recommendations.

Have you got a story to tell? Would you like to become a PSE columnist? If so, click here.


Mike Carr   15/12/2017 at 14:34

The independence of Scrutiny would be much improved if the government made local authorities elect their scrutiny panels by secret ballot and alternative vote as they do for parliamentary select committees.

Brian   18/12/2017 at 17:26

Executive committees more often than not make decisions based on politics rather than actual evidence. Scrutiny committees should be compelled to listen to hard evidence and have the power to reverse decisions. There should be a system of penalties for failure if it is necessary to follow up with legal proceedings.

Add your comment



public sector executive tv

more videos >

latest public sector news

‘More to be done’ to build public confidence in reporting suspected child abuse

16/03/2018‘More to be done’ to build public confidence in reporting suspected child abuse

More than two in five adults who have worried about the welfare of a child have not reported their concerns, new research has revealed. In a rec... more >
Over a quarter of secondary schools in deficit

16/03/2018Over a quarter of secondary schools in deficit

The proportion of local authority maintained secondary schools in deficit has nearly trebled in four years, a new report has revealed. ‘Sc... more >
‘Wholly unacceptable’ that central gov does not have clear answer to benefits of LEPs

16/03/2018‘Wholly unacceptable’ that central gov does not have clear answer to benefits of LEPs

The Greater Cambridge Greater Peterborough Local Enterprise Partnership (GCGP LEP) is the latest example of the Ministry of Housing, Communities an... more >

editor's comment

25/10/2017Take a moment to celebrate

Devolution, restructuring and widespread service reform: from a journalist’s perspective, it’s never been a more exciting time to report on the public sector. That’s why I could not be more thrilled to be taking over the reins at PSE at this key juncture. There could not be a feature that more perfectly encapsulates this... read more >

last word

The importance of openness after Grenfell

The importance of openness after Grenfell

Following the recent Grenfell Tower tragedy, Lord Porter, chairman of the LGA, argues that if the public are going to have faith in the safety testing process then everything must be out in the o... more > more last word articles >
Leader resigns after Whitehall report calls for failing council to be split up

16/03/2018Leader resigns after Whitehall report calls for failing council to be split up

The leader of Northamptonshire County Council has announced her resignation after a government report recommended the impoverished authority should be split into two smaller unitary councils. ... more >
Javid ‘minded to’ approve unitary plans for Buckinghamshire

12/03/2018Javid ‘minded to’ approve unitary plans for Buckinghamshire

Sajid Javid has today announced that he is minded to approve plans which would see a large unitary authority created from the six existing authorities in Buckinghamshire. Under the current p... more >

the raven's daily blog

Apprenticeship levy – five myths busted

05/03/2018Apprenticeship levy – five myths busted

On the first day of National Apprenticeship Week 2018 (NAW 2018), the director of the National Apprenticeship Service, Sue Husband, challenges some of the key myths around the apprenticeship levy. NAW 2018 takes place from 5 to 9 March. It will be a week-long celebration of apprenticeships in England designed to showcase how apprenti... more >
read more blog posts from 'the raven' >


Building a more diverse society

05/03/2018Building a more diverse society

Karl Wilding, policy director at the National Council for Voluntary Organisations (NCVO), argues that diverse membership in charities and local g... more >
Developing our future leaders

05/03/2018Developing our future leaders

Kerry Bishop, apprenticeship and qualification development manager at the LGSS (pictured), provides an insight into how the organisation is suppo... more >
What's next for BIM?

05/03/2018What's next for BIM?

After some mostly positive findings in last year’s National Building Information Modelling (BIM) Report, PSE’s Luana Salles considers... more >
BIM: Reaping the rewards

26/02/2018BIM: Reaping the rewards

Although austerity has been a barrier to adopting Building Information Modelling (BIM), continued investment in these tools can greatly benefit t... more >


Keeping London safe

05/03/2018Keeping London safe

Theo Blackwell, London’s first-ever chief digital officer (CDO), speaks to PSE’s Luana Salles about the role he plays in ensuring the... more >
BIM: Digitising the public sector

19/02/2018BIM: Digitising the public sector

PSE’s Josh Mines talks to Stephen Crompton, CTO at GroupBC, and Stuart Bell, the company’s sales and marketing director, about how Bu... more >
Duncan Selbie: The energy of devolution

19/02/2018Duncan Selbie: The energy of devolution

The NHS plays a part in keeping the country well – but when it comes to places and their people, local government has a major role to fulfi... more >
Are we taking a risk on education?

14/12/2017Are we taking a risk on education?

Adrian Prandle, director of economic strategy and negotiations at the National Education Union (NEU), questions the stark lack of announcements a... more >

public sector focus

View all News